top of page
Single-family home on tree lined street in one of Nashville's iconic neighborhoods.

It's time to stand up to reckless zoning policies

The million dollar lie: Exposing Nashville's "Missing Middle" swindle

For 15 years, Nashville leaders have peddled a myth: build more, and affordability will follow. This is the flawed gospel behind the Metro Council's crusade for "Missing Middle" upzoning.


It was a lie during the "tall skinny" boom, and it’s a lie now. This isn't a housing plan; it’s a swindle—a betrayal of public trust that fuels speculation and guarantees luxury development.


Nashville is choking on a surplus of unsold luxury housing, yet the Council is doubling down on the policies that created the glut.

How Nashville can actually address the affordability crisis

A real strategy must come first. Surprisingly, Nashville already has one: the Unified Housing Strategy (UHS) 2025. It identifies the actual problem—a shortage of affordable housing for the city’s lowest-income and workforce families—and recommends starting with those who are most in need.

The current rezoning push promises affordability, but rarely delivers it where it is needed most. The term is used so broadly that it often applies to housing that is priced beyond what working-class residents can afford. True affordability means homes for the workforce and those with lower incomes, not just smaller units for higher earners. The Missing Middle approach may help a narrow slice of upper-tier workforce households—but only in theory. In practice, 15 years of zoning reform have yielded more expensive units, rather than more affordable ones.

Market-rate vacancy is already over 10%, showing that supply exists, but not at the prices people in crisis can afford. Nashville should return to the UHS—a plan it already has—focusing on affordable, targeted solutions, rather than increasing density for a market already overserved.

The real impacts of bad planning proposals

Modern zoning reform sounds good, but in low-density neighborhoods, it often puts profits over people. It brings in expensive development, pushes up land prices, and causes property taxes to rise fast. These changes can disrupt the quiet character of our communities. The folks who’ve lived here the longest usually don’t see the benefits — but they do pay the price.

A man is concerned about the latest property tax increase in Nashville.
IMPACTS

Unintended tax increases

Redevelopment that prioritizes high-end infill and upzoning densification raises property values—artificially inflating taxes, not because of homeowner improvements, but by enabling developer-investors to extract value from zoning changes. 

High-priced tall housing being built in Nashville neighborhoods.
IMPACTS

More homes, higher prices – no affordability gain

Zoning reforms have mostly added high-priced housing. The theory that these units will eventually become affordable through "filtering" hasn’t been supported by real-world data. In fact, affordability is eroding as lower-cost options disappear faster than new ones arrive.

A diverse neighborhood group angry that Nashville City Hall is not listening to their concerns about un-checked planning.
IMPACTS

The disappearing voice of neighborhoods

Nashville’s housing reforms promised community-centered solutions—but what’s actually happening is a quiet sidelining of neighborhood voices and working families.

Speculators and investors development is driving up housing prices in Nashville.
IMPACTS

Speculation driving up land costs

Calls to increase zoning capacity often promise affordability, but they trigger a land rush. As density rises, so do land values, drawing in speculators, investors, and developers and displacing long-time residents.

A couple on their front porch is worried about gentrification and displacement in a historical Nashville neighborhood.
IMPACTS

Cultural and demographic displacement

In the name of crisis, top-down housing policies and promises echo past government programs — displacing communities and erasing their continuity, culture, and the affordability they were promised but never received.

Heavy equipment cutting down trees and diminishing Nashville’s tree canopy.
IMPACTS

Vanishing tree canopy

As development accelerates, Nashville is losing its mature tree canopy—a critical part of its identity and livability. Once viewed as "a city in a park," entire neighborhoods now face tree loss, erosion, and intensifying heat.

As residents of Nashville, we see these planning proposals through the lens of lived experience shaped by years of investing time, care, and resources into our communities. While we understand the importance of managing growth and addressing housing needs, we believe these goals must be pursued with a clear understanding of neighborhood context, local identity, and long-term livability.

SONN is not resistant to change. We simply demand city leaders and planners to implement thoughtful, place-based decision-making that respects the people who already call these neighborhoods home.

Get all the facts

Issues around housing affordability are complex. The media often presents the perspectives of special interest groups – politicians, developers, and outside consultants. And what is reported is often purposely over simplified. We believe you should have the whole story. Below are important facts that you should know about.

concerned_citizens_nashville.jpg
ANALYSIS
The housing supply is there — the affordability is not
Construction Site in Suburban Neighborhood.jpg
EXPOSED
RN and RL zoning: tools without rules
nashville-housing-swindle-2.jpg
EXPOSED
Nashville’s housing swindle: how the Metro Council’s "Missing Middle"  fairy tales fuel an affordability crisis
houses_nations.jpg
ALERTS
A top-down transformation for The Nations: an analysis of council member Rollin Horton’s rezoning plan
uhs_mockup.jpg
IMPACTS
Solving Nashville’s housing challenge: a strategy built on evidence, not ideology
I&H_posters_mockup_opt.jpg
IMPACTS
4 things every Nashville homeowner must know about proposed zoning
Inappropriate dense housing being constructed next to a single family home.
ALERTS
How middle housing and zoning changes could reshape Nashville’s neighborhoods
Nashville's Nations Neighborhood is experiencing rising housing prices and displacement of residents.
OUTCOMES
Hope undelivered: what 15 years of reform promised and failed to deliver
Nashville City Council
OUTCOMES
Planning in the public interest: a tale of two processes
"Tall skinny" housing in Nashville neighborhoods that is not sloving the afforability issue.
OUTCOMES
Why building more market-rate homes is not creating affordability in Nashville
An older couple concerned about gentrification and displacement from their neighborhood.
IMPACTS
Gentrification is redefining who gets to stay
Forested areas in Nashville safeguard biodiversity, climate stability, and scenic character of the city.
IMPACTS
Champion the environment and the Highland Rim Forest
Neighborhood community meeting where Nashville residents give input on planning.
SOLUTIONS

A better way forward: from non-performing promises to focused housing solutions

A family can't find an affordable house.
EXPOSED
Where have all the affordable houses gone?
Man working on his budget to try and buy a house in Nashville.
EXPOSED
Upzoning will raise housing prices, why are we doing this?
A modest single-family home in a low-density Nashville neighborhood.
IMPACTS
Why single family home-owners should worry about zoning reform and upzoning

Who we are

Save Our Nashville Neighborhoods, Inc. (SONNinc or SONN) is a grassroots, neighborhood-led coalition working to protect community voice, community vision, affordability, and livability across Davidson County. Formed in District 23 and now active citywide, SONN helps residents decode zoning and housing reform, challenge who actually benefits from proposed changes, and advocate for policies that reflect the lived experience of real people, especially working families and long-time neighbors, the very people who create the communities that give Nashville its unique character.

We invite residents, leaders, and policymakers alike to work with us, not in opposition, but in collaboration. SONN offers a space where shared goals can take shape, where practical solutions rise from real neighborhoods, not imposed blueprints. Add your voice. Bring your ideas. Help us build a better path forward—one that genuinely serves the people who call this city home.

Who we are

 Nashville housing in perspective 

Back in 2015 Nashville recognized there was a wave of growth coming and expanded the zoning codes to allow more density. The plan, called NashvilleNext, was adopted to allow for more density in areas that make the most sense – without destroying our neighborhoods or displacing long-time residents. The plan worked. In fact Nashville is number two in the country after Houston for adding housing in the core areas and is a model for cities accross the country [attribution]. What's more, the rate of growth in Nashville is slowing according to macrotrends.net, so the Next plan is still the best plan. --THE NUMBERS NEED TO BE VALIDATED AND ATTRIBUTED--

New housing units currently being built in Nashville

13,000

Davidson County

From ?????

Updated 

Building permits approved just in March this year

1289

Davidson County

From Federal Reserve Bank data

Updated May 10, 2025

Houses currently for sale under $375,000

162

Davidson County

MLS residential listings

Updated May 10, 2025

Average days a home is are on the market

51.5

Davidson County

From MLS

Updated May 10, 2025

Join us!

Join Nashville's Neighborhood presevation movement!

Join us!

Frequently asked questions

bottom of page